Is Price of Anarchy the Right Measure for Load-Balancing Games?
نویسندگان
چکیده
Price of Anarchy is an oft-used worst-case measure of the inefficiency of non-cooperative decentralized architectures. For a non-cooperative load-balancing game with two classes of servers and for a finite or infinite number of dispatchers, we show that the Price of Anarchy is an overly pessimistic measure that does not reflect the performance obtained in most instances of the problem. We explicitly characterize the worst-case traffic conditions for the efficiency of non-cooperative load-balancing schemes, and show that, contrary to a common belief, the worst inefficiency is in general not achieved in heavy-traffic.
منابع مشابه
Efficiency analysis of load balancing games with and without activation costs
In this paper, we study two models of resource allocation games: the classical load balancing game and its new variant involving resource activation costs. The resources we consider are identical and the social costs of the games are utilitarian, which are the average of all individual players’ costs. Using the social costs we assess the quality of pure Nash equilibria in terms of the price of ...
متن کاملThe Price of Stochastic Anarchy
We consider the solution concept of stochastic stability, and propose the price of stochastic anarchy as an alternative to the price of (Nash) anarchy for quantifying the cost of selfishness and lack of coordination in games. As a solution concept, the Nash equilibrium has disadvantages that the set of stochastically stable states of a game avoid: unlike Nash equilibria, stochastically stable s...
متن کاملSelfish Load Balancing
Suppose that a set of weighted tasks shall be assigned to a set of machines with possibly different speeds such that the load is distributed evenly among the machines. In computer science, this problem is traditionally treated as an optimization problem. One of the classical objectives is to minimize the makespan, i.e., the maximum load over all machines. Here we study a natural game theoretic ...
متن کاملCongestion Games, Load Balancing, and Price of Anarchy
Imagine a set of self-interested clients, each of whom must choose a server from a permissible set. A server’s latency is inversely proportional to its speed, but it grows linearly with (or, more generally, as the pth power of) the number of clients matched to it. Many emerging Internet-centric applications such as peer-to-peer networks, multi-player online games and distributed computing platf...
متن کاملOn the Inefficiency Ratio of Stable Equilibria in Congestion Games
Price of anarchy and price of stability are the primary notions for measuring the efficiency (i.e. the social welfare) of the outcome of a game. Both of these notions focus on extreme cases: one is defined as the inefficiency ratio of the worst-case equilibrium and the other as the best one. Therefore, studying these notions often results in discovering equilibria that are not necessarily the m...
متن کامل